Sometimes, if something does not work on a Linux installation, one may find that frustrating. You hope for the best and try to find a solution – and in contrast to Windows I always had the impression that with Linux you have a chance to solve or circumvent your problems after some time. So, after the frustration about a Linux problem comes the interest in its details, then hope and after some work and information gathering even an improved knowledge about system configuration aspects and eventually some workaround … At least most of the times …
However, yesterday morning, when the cause of anger was a combination of Microsoft, Skype AND PulseAudio, I thought this was too much of an ordeal and there was not much room left for hope. Having last used Skype successfully on Aug, 1st, I needed to use it urgently again yesterday. But I had to learn: It does not work anymore despite the fact that I had not changed my system. No login to the Skype service possible. It took some time and tests to find out that, since some days ago, they only allow for connections from 4.3 Skype clients. After an update to the latest version I could log in to Skype again – however, sound did not work any more on my Linux system with – of course – plain ALSA. My blood pressure broke some records ….
It’s no secret: I neither like Microsoft, nor their proprietary Skype nor PulseAudio as a sound system layer for Linux.
Although, if you once forget about the security and confidentiality risks associated with the use of Skype, there is one thing I have to admit:
Until the beginning of August Skype (4.2) worked quite well on Linux. Something I can not at all say about PulseAudio. And Skype is handy (although only available as a 32 bit solution), it works with good performance world wide – and (unfortunately) many of my customers use it. As I cannot convince all customers to change to a Linux desktop I adapted in the past to this situation and used Skype on a separate Linux system, which I boot on a laptop only for Skype sessions.
Up to now, my motives for that separate Linux were security related. Now, it seems there is one more reason to do so:
Skype 4.2 clients and below for Linux can no longer connect to the Skype service. [Why ???? – a really good question … which makes me somewhat suspicious by the way … ] So, you have to upgrade to Skype 4.3. However, Skype 4.3 ignores any ALSA sound configuration without PulseAudio. It took me some time to find that out. See:
(Interestingly, in this last article Microsoft only refers to Ubuntu – maybe Skype only will work on Ubuntu, soon?.)
The requirement of PulseAudio – that’s were the real frustration and anger for me begins. Microsoft forces me to use a special Linux sound system layer – which from my own experience generates more problems than it solves under many circumstances and on many systems.
Can a day start worse?
Ok, Microsoft does not force me to use Skype, after all. And, actually, I do not care so much to configure a separate bootable Linux version on my laptop which – for the sake of a working Skype – may use PulseAudio. As long as I do not have to use it otherwise and especially not on my desktops 🙂 . And the good thing with Opensuse is that (up to now !) PulseAudio can be deactivated relatively easily and system wide by YaST without having to reboot everything 🙂 . And even regarding the boot time for a special Linux installation as in my case – shutdown and boot times are pretty short on SSD driven laptops of the present generation. (Ironically
this is partially due to “systemd” from just the same developer as PulseAudio.)
However, one can even understand that and why Microsoft wanted to use a common layer for an existing variety of possible underlying Linux sound architectures. So, the real dilemma is: Why do all major Linux distributions promote and configure a sound system layer and associated applications which after years of upgrades still are a pain in the ass for many Linux users ? One rather desperate person wrote this article last year:
Believe me, I understand this guy. I, personally, have had bad experiences with many soundcards and PulseAudio on Opensuse Linux for years. Crackling sound, distorted sound, sliders in “pavumeter” not all working as expected for multichannel cards, sound delay, sudden sound level increases to 100 %, some applications no longer working after PA upgrades, …. you name it. After some time with such experiences and one set of destroyed speakers, it became a habit for me to deactivate or deinstall PulseAudio on almost all of my Opensuse installations directly after the first system setup – which did a lot of good for my nerves, the soundcards and the speakers. Pure ALSA did and does a perfect job for me.
See also the small but interesting statistics on the following blog article:
I agree with the author of that blog: Either, the Linux distributors
- find an alternative or finance the work on an alternative
- or the effort to change PulseAudio to something useful must be intensified.
Not only because of the Steam games engine …
- I have an additional reason to use a separate Linux installation for Skype.
- I am looking for Skype alternatives, usable both on Linux and Windows. Yesterday, I tried Jitsi/XMPP with a jabber account on a German server. Works well within the country, at least. What I like about Jitsi is the end to end encryption. I also like its simple interface and the fact that it is available both for Linux and Windows. However, when I tried to communicate with my wife, who presently is in Norway, the performance with sound and video transmission in parallel was very poor despite ADSL on both sides. But she was using a German server, too. We did not yet try with accounts on German and Norwegian servers. But this is stuff for another article.
- I see some positive aspects in Skype’s present dependency on Pulseaudio, too. Maybe, other Linux users now start looking for Skype alternatives, too. And some geeks and Linux companies may find interest in developing such alternatives or supplying servers for it. E.g., Tox (see: https://tox.im/) is under development. Or, the pressure on the PulseAudio people may grow to eventually improve their baby to the level of reasonable usability.
So, eventually, there may be some hope even after yesterday’s suffering …